Sunday, February 25, 2024

Latest Posts

Calorie Deficit Vs Low Carb

Calorie Counting Or Carb Counting: Which Works Best

Low carb is better than calorie counting

The truth of the matter is, that there are different weight loss interventions that work for different people. Some people like the rigidity of calorie counting or they feel better when they lower their carb intake, but if they dont work for you or they really trigger you by making you feel like youre on a mental rollercoaster, there are other ways to do it.

If you know you need to lose weight , then consider whether its time to look at your relationship with food first and foremost. Its not sexy and its not going to get you the beach body by Christmas if you start doing it in October. But being able to make healthy, conscious and consistent food choices is what gets you there in the end without the fear of it coming back on.

Hey! Im Zoe Morosini, an Australian based nutritionist on a mission to show every woman that wants to be a healthy weight that she doesnt have to lose her mind trying.

Cons Of Counting Calories

* Although counting calories keep you within the boundaries of the recommended 2,000 calories per day, it doesnt address your nutritional requirements.

* Many people get in a rush to lose weight and drop their calorie intake below safe levels. You may lose more weight temporarily, but you can also lose muscle mass because your body goes into starvation mode. Consult with your primary healthcare provider about how many calories you should be consuming each day to lose weight.

/9foods Allowed And Restricted In Low

Some calorie-counting diets focus only on calories where you can eat whatever you want. But when you are counting on calories, it is more important to make sure that every bite you consume should be healthy and nutritious. Fill your daily calories with lean protein, vegetables, beans, whole grains, fruits, nuts and fat-free dairy products. Avoid sugar-sweetened candy, baked goods, desserts, sweets and beverages.

Also Check: 1000 Calorie Diet Meal Plan 14 Days

Keto Diet Vs Low Carb: Whats The Difference

They might seem like similar approaches, there are some key differences between the keto diet vs low carb. We asked the experts to unpack them

Keto diet vs low carb: whats the difference and which is better? Although the two diets both involve cutting carbs and can help with weight loss, the keto diet is a far more restrictive way of eating and involves limiting carb intake and eating a high amount of fat, with moderate protein.

Keto means the body has switched into ketosis and is using fat instead of glucose for fuel, says diet expert Heidi Normanton, founder of Heylo . Meanwhile low carb diets limit the amount of carbohydrates consumed, especially simple and refined ones found in sugary foods, pasta and bread. Going low carb helps regulate blood sugar but it doesnt produce ketosis, so the body will first use the glucose stored as energy, then move onto fat for fuel.

Its important to have an understanding of your body and the calories and nutrients required for it to function effectively before starting a new diet, adds elite coach Farren Morgan, who runs The Tactical Athlete . He advises speaking to a dietician or a health professional first.

In this article we look at the key differences between the keto diet vs low carb, so you can decide if either plan is right for you.

Calorie Deficit Vs Keto Diet For Weight Loss

Low Calorie vs. Low Carb?

In the short term, both calorie deficit vs keto are successful weight lose strategies because they emphasize eating nutrient-dense, less processed foods. However, in the long run, the calorie deficit technique is more suited to persons who want a wider range of food options in their diet.

Dr. Alexandra M Johnstone of the Rowett Research Institute in Aberdeen studied seventeen obese men to see how a high protein keto diet affected their satiety and hunger levels.

According to the findings, “in the short run, high-protein, low-carbohydrate ketogenic diets considerably decrease hunger and food intake more than high-protein, medium-carbohydrate non ketogenic diets” Johnstone, Alexandra M et al. 2008 .

Is the keto diet superior to the calorie deficit diet? Overall, calorie deficit is superior than keto for weight reduction because calorie deficit provides for more food options and is more feasible for long-term calorie restriction. The keto diet, on the other hand, is mostly comprised of meat and dairy, which may be both dull and costly.

Don’t Miss: Low Fat Low Carb Snacks

What Should I Take Away From This

One important aspect of this trial we need to consider, and one that is often overlooked, is interindividual variability.

As you can see in Figure 2, weight changes differed drastically within both groups â ranging from 70 lbs lost to 24 lbs gained . Each bar represents the weight change of a single participant. Even when accounting for the â10% of participants who gained weight, the combined weight loss in this study was an impressive â6,600 lbs .

There are a couple of things to note here:

  • Overall, the graphs are quite similar .
  • Studies attempt to discern an overall effect, and often report nothing else â even when individual responses are all over the place.

A second important aspect to consider is adherence. In the beginning of the study, all participants were instructed to consume either â¤20 g of fat or â¤20 g of carbs for the first two months, after which they could increase either their fat or carb intake to levels they felt they could sustain indefinitely. By the end of the trial, the vast majority had not been able to maintain such low levels. The final dietary recalls reported an average daily fat intake of â57 g and an average daily carb intake of â132 g .

Real-life applicability matters greatly when extrapolating from a studyâs results. The results from this study send a clear message that, when choosing an eating style, sustainability is a component whose importance cannot be understated.

Final Thoughts: The Debate Between Low Calorie Versus Low Carb Share The Need For Portion Control

Nutritional experts encourage everyone to learn how to portion their meals and snacks correctly. In the last two decades, food portions in America have increased so subtly that you probably havent noticed. While controlling your portions is necessary for a low-calorie diet, it isnt always easy to judge a smaller portion sizes calorie content by looking at the nutritional label.

When considering the low calorie vs. low carb debate, portion control is even more critical for counting carbs because you wont always have a nutritional label. However, its not difficult to memorize portions of your favorite foods to make healthy meal options. Some whole foods, like most salad greens, have negligible amounts of carbohydrates, so you dont have to count them.

If you want to lose weight and get healthier, you have several dieting options available. When you consider low calorie vs. low carb diets, be aware of the pros and cons of each option and realize they both require some easy calculations and portion control. Before starting any diet or exercise regimen, consult your primary healthcare provider or a registered dietician.

You May Like: How Many Calories Should I Be Eating

The Argument That We Excrete Excess Nutrients

Some people are saying that we will excrete excess nutrients if we dont use them in terms of protein and fats. This study shows that we will only excrete about 3 grams of fat when we eat 2800 calories a day .

Another study shows that over a 14 day window and multiple diets the amount of nutrients lost from excretion is only about 4% of the diet.

We dont just excrete the nutrients we eat the energy we eat gets absorbed and used or stored in the body.

Gary Taubes on Calories

Lets take a look at what Gary Taubes has said, as I know people will be thinking of him as they read this article.

The fatal flaw in this reasoning is that we dont have the same energy expenditure as our fat mass increases. I just want to point out that the calories in/calories out system dont claim to predict exact energy expenditure, weight gain, or weight loss. Its just a system that shows how energy intake and expenditure are linked with energy storage and energy loss for the average person.

Whether the system is exactly accurate down to 20 calories or not doesnt really matter, as thats not the intended purpose. What it does is give a reference point for people to individualize their intended weight loss.

Let me dispute what Gary Taubes said with Gary Taubes, in a 2010 interview with Andreas Eenfeldt, Gary Taubes about why we get fat.

In his book Why We Get Fat, chapter six: Thermodynamics for Dummies, Part 1.

Calorie Deficit Vs Keto Diet

Low Calorie or Low Carb Diet?

In general, the calorie deficit is a state of the body where you consume fewer calories than the body requires. On the other hand, if you eat more calories than your body needs youre in a calorie surplus. Another name for calorie deficit is negative energy balance.

For example, if your body needs 3000 calories per day to maintain your current weight, simply reducing 300-500 calories will put you into a deficit.

On the other hand, the ketogenic diet is a high-fat, low-carbohydrate, and moderate-protein diet, which helps to increase insulin sensitivity and promote weight loss.

What is insulin sensitivity? Insulin sensitivity refers to how responsive is the body to glucose from the food. High insulin sensitivity means the body can efficiently use insulin to redistribute the glucose from the blood. Low insulin sensitivity means the body cant use glucose efficiently for energy.

If we compare the two, the ketogenic diet works by creating a calorie deficit. Keep in mind that you can be in a calorie deficit on any food, regardless if you eat carbs or not.

Also Check: Alcohol With The Least Calories

You Dont Need To Cut Carbs

Cutting straight to the point, you DO NOT need to cut carbohydrates out of your diet to lose weight. In fact, weight loss is completely independent of macronutrient balance . The only and I mean the ONLY true factor that matters in weight loss is whether or not you are in a calorie deficit . IF you are in a calorie deficit you WILL lose weight overtime, thats it, its that simple . Any balance of the three macronutrients will lead to the same net result of weight loss. Believe it or not you would be able to lose weight on a diet composed completely of fats. Thats right, you could lose bodyfat, eating only fat, pretty crazy right?

/6low Crab Vs Low Fat: Know The Difference

Being inclined towards trying new diet options and experimenting with the already existing ones is understandable. It is common knowledge that while trying to lose weight it is imperative to cut on carbohydrates and unhealthy fats and increase protein intake so that muscle mass increases but fat decreases. Keeping this fact in mind, there are mainly two diets that people find themselves attracted towards- Low Fat diet or Low Carb diet. There is indeed no one specific diet that can help everyone because all of us have different body types and unique processes but if you still wish to try one of these diets, here is everything that you need to know about them:

Don’t Miss: Eating Well 1200 Calorie Meal Plan

Low Carb Vs Caloric Deficit

Wich one is better for a Person with 25% bodyfat? I am trying low carb, but i am not sure wich one is better to lose fat. I am working out 6 days a week + 30min of cardio. I always see bodybuilders who eat rice with chicken or something like that. Should i stick to my low carb diet or switch to calorie deficit?

  • 10-08-2015, 01:29 PM#2
  • Location: Flushing, New York, United States
    Age: 42
    Rep Power: 91021

    Originally Posted by BigDreamer54Wich one is better for a Person with 25% bodyfat? I am trying low carb, but i am not sure wich one is better to lose fat. I am working out 6 days a week + 30min of cardio. I always see bodybuilders who eat rice with chicken or something like that. Should i stick to my low carb diet or switch to calorie deficit? Regardless of what approach you decide to take, they are all dependent on there being a caloric deficit in order for them to work.

  • 10-08-2015, 01:29 PM#3
  • Posts: 12,140
    Rep Power: 48655

    Calorie deficit with proper macros is essential for fat loss. Low carbs or not is just personal preference.

  • 10-08-2015, 01:41 PM#4
  • Man I’m too slow today.I’m just gunna reply to all the threads with “yeah, what they said!”

  • 10-08-2015, 03:23 PM#5
  • Posts: 5,537
    Rep Power: 27197
  • 10-08-2015, 09:22 PM#6
  • Rep Power: 441

    Desire > Willingness > Strategy > Execution > Consistency > Perseverance > Reflection > Improvement = Continued Success

  • 10-09-2015, 01:38 AM#7
  • Calorie Deficit Or Keto For Weight Loss

    Whole Health Source: A New Human Trial Undermines the Carbohydrate ...

    In the short term, both calorie deficit and keto are effective for weight loss because they prioritize consuming nutrient-dense and minimally process foods. However, in the long term, the calorie deficit approach is more suitable for people who like to have more variety of food choices in their diet.

    I personally dont like doing keto because I always feel more hungry if I only eat meat, eggs, and fats. On the other hand, foods that have high satiety score like potatoes or oatmeal helps me to stay fuller for longer.


    Dr. Alexandra M Johnstone from the Rowett Research Institute in Aberdeen has documented seventeen obese men and the effect of a high protein keto diet on satiety and hunger levels.

    The results showed that In the short term, high-protein, low-carbohydrate ketogenic diets reduce hunger and lower food intake significantly more than do high-protein, medium-carbohydrate nonketogenic diets .

    Is the keto diet better than calorie deficit? Overall, the calorie deficit is better than keto for weight loss because calorie deficit allows for more food choices, which is more realistic to continue calorie restriction in the long term. On the other hand, the keto diet is limited to mainly meat and dairy, which not only can get boring but also more expensive.

    You May Like: Low Carbs For Weight Loss

    Is Calorie Counting Effective For Short And Long Term For Weight Loss

    In contrast to simply eating less carbs , calorie counting works by keeping track of your overall energy intake.

    In other words, you dont need to worry about how many carbs, fats or proteins you eat, you just have to worry about how much energy you eat across your day and week. You work out how many calories you generally expend in your day, take about 500 calories off it and track your food so that you dont eat more than that.

    Popular with the fitness industry, calorie counting can also be effective for weight loss if you stick to it.

    Its just as simple as carb counting in its conceptualisation, but for some it tends to be tedious when youre first starting out .

    There are a number of other pitfalls too. Firstly, tracking calories isnt always super accurate, as energy balance is influenced by a number of different factors. Unlike low carb diets, calorie counting doesnt dictate WHAT you eat, as long as you dont eat less than your daily calorie expenditureand therein lies the problem.

    First, calorie counting doesnt equal health.

    As long as you only eat your allocated number of calories, you can eat whatever you want and technically fulfil the criteria for weight loss. A key example of this is in the consumption of fat.

    Already a big no from us there.

    So which should you choose? Are you beginning to get the idea that were not a huge fan of either?

    Periods Have Stopped After Eating Low Carb

    My 14-year old daughter has had fairly regular periods for two years now. She started eating low-carb approximately six months ago due to some food intolerances and skin issues she was having. Those symptoms are now sorted and shes the healthiest physically that shes ever been. However, three months ago her periods stopped completely.

    She has not lost any weight since going low carb, though she may have lost some fat but she has always been quite small for her age. She currently weighs 47 kg and is 161 cm tall.

    Are her lack of periods something to be concerned about or is this a common occurrence when starting a low-carb diet for someone her age?


    Dr. Fox:

    Great question: No, I would not think low-carb high-fat would cause stress enough to lose periods or cause significant delays. Excessive exercise is the single most common reason for women to have cycle irregularity or loss of periods.

    Also is she getting enough calories? . Relative starvation is common among teens. Their friends are feeding them the party line of calorie restriction to solve weight problems, so better look into this. She may need an evaluation for this with thyroid and other endocrine problems as more unusual causes.

    Good luck.

    Also Check: Swiss Miss Hot Chocolate Calories

    Does Eating High Carbs But Low Calories Equal Weight Loss

    Arthur Erickson

    If you love carbs and want to lose weight, theres good news, as long as you eat a low-calorie diet, the pounds will come off no matter what you eat. That said, overloading on carbohydrates is detrimental to your health, as is getting your carbs from the wrong sources. Talk to your doctor before making major changes to your diet or starting a weight loss plan.

    Calories and Weight Loss

    Whether you fill up on carbs or protein, the amount of calories you consume primarily dictates whether you lose or gain weight. A safe, effective low-calorie diet is typically 1,200 to 1,500 calories per day for women or 1,800 to 2,000 calories per day for men. Eating this amount creates a calorie deficit, meaning your body uses more energy than you take in so it must burn body fat for fuel. For optimal weight loss results, engage in regular exercise as well.

    Carbs and Weight Loss

    In a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2009, researchers placed obese participants on one of four reduced-calorie diets for two years target carbohydrate intake for each diet ranged from 35 to 65 percent of total calories. Participants also attended periodic instructional meetings. By the end of the study, researchers found no difference between the diets the main factor for weight loss success was attending meetings, regardless of carb consumption.

    Complex vs. Simple Carbs
    Choosing Carbs Wisely

    Latest Posts

    Popular Articles

    Stay in touch

    To be updated with all the latest news, offers and special announcements.